This week, I finished lettering the next chapter of the Legends of the Dracorex graphic novel. Here is the first of six pages of “The Colony” to whet your appetite.
Artist Eliseu Gouveia once again did an amazing job bringing my original script and rough page layouts to life. He’s an outstanding collaborator who not only came up with ingeniuous visual solutions to some problems that had me stumped on page one, but also found inspiration in the recent solar eclipse and took the intitiative to add a darkened sun to a ritual sacrifice scene.
My original script did not call for an eclipse, but the darkened sun was so perfect for the scene that I altered the final script to fit. The completion of this chapter leaves us with one more episode to finish this summer, plus a full-color cover illustration, then I’ll be ready to publish the 48-page graphic novel.
If you’re following developments in AI-generated art, then you’re familiar with the negative criticisms: AI is garbage. AI is racist. AI is plagiarism. AI is putting artists out of business. In the face of such backlash—all of which I take seriously—why would I even consider using AI to generate illustrations for my latest book?
The only criticism that might actually hurt my feelings is that my decisions are putting artists out of business. The reality is that Gods of Titanand Other Tales generated more income for other artists than any of my previous works, because I hired a professional comic-book illustrator to draw a six-page story that’s included in the book, and we plan to work together again in the near future. And in The Second Omnibus, there’s another six-page comic-book story I paid an old friend to draw, plus I hired a talented young artist from the Philippines for the cover illustration.
In my work as an editor of other people’s books, I’ve referred several projects to a UK-based artist who does excellent book cover design, original illustrations, and maps. I’ve also used Shutterstock to get images for several of my own books, and though I can’t imagine the artists get paid much for the image licensing, I have to assume that if the scenario was completely worthless to them, then they wouldn’t have a relationship with Shutterstock.
It’s also worth considering that, as far as my fiction series and most of my other books go, I am the artist. My interiors and covers have often featured my original drawings and paintings, logo designs, and cover designs. So who would I be putting out of business—myself?
With that context in mind, I enjoyed playing with AI to add some visual flair to the latest book. I got images I thought were pretty cool for the chapters and cover, far more than I had the time or skill to draw or paint on my own, and within my limited production budget. It wasn’t like anyone else was going to get paid for illustrating the book. It was either AI or me or nobody.
While exploring this relatively new technology, I learned a lot through research and reading and discussions with other creative types, and thought more about the implications of AI than I would have otherwise. It’s been a recurring topic on this blog in the two years I’ve been working on Gods of Titan.
I also found ways to use AI that would help the artists I’ve employed or referred to. By playing with the robots and feeding them concepts I was working on, I could eventually get visual results that depicted a certain mood, or color scheme, or scenario I was going for—something I could show my artists not with the intention of asking them to replicate it but as a springboard for stimulating ideas and inspirations, a starting point they could work from to do their own thing. Sometimes it’s easier for everyone if you can show someone an image rather than write a thousand words telling them about what you have in mind—kind of like taking a photo from a magazine to your hair stylist instead of trying to explain the haircut you want.
And as a writer and artist, I found ways to bounce ideas back and forth with AI image generators and chatbots to initiate a flow of creative ideas. This was especially helpful to me as I haven’t had a critique group to work with in a few years. And even if I did, no one wants me calling them at three in the morning to argue the moral implications of building a positron machine to send messages back in time. But robots? They don’t mind my weird insomnia at all.
Can AI be used for nefarious purposes? Of course. A hammer can be used to build a house to shelter people, or it can be used to bash in their skulls. Nuclear fission can provide electric power to an entire a city, or blast it off the face of the Earth. A tool or tech is not inherently good or evil, though its uses most definitely can be.
Finally, from the philosophical perspective of a lifelong reader and writer of science fiction, it seems natural to creatively explore a technology that once dwelt exclusively in the realm of fiction but has now become real. Incorporating a sci-fi tool in the production of a sci-fi book feels like too tempting of an opportunity to pass by! If I had a total lack of curiosity about AI, I would probably not even be qualified to be writing SF in the twenty-first century. When writing about the asteroid-mining frontier, how could I not be interested in the current real-life frontiers in space exploration, robotics, genetics, and more? Did you know a new aircraft is being designed to explore Mars, and that its name is MAGGIE? Meteor Mags would love it!
While I understand the criticisms and fears about AI, and I feel they are all legitimate things worth discussing and addressing through public policy and efforts to improve the tech, I couldn’t see those things as reasons to not take the robots for a test drive and see what they could do. The printing press might have put a lot of monks out of a job of transcribing manuscripts by hand. The camera was once feared as putting painters out of business. Desktop word-processing software might have threatened the jobs of typists. And on and on. But technology keeps moving forward, and creative people can move forward with it. The future keeps arriving with every passing second. What will we do with it?
Addicted to action and beholden to no one, a hell-raising space pirate and her indestructible calico cat confront the horrors of the asteroid-mining frontier, from massive monsters to revolting robots, and much, much more.
Join Meteor Mags and her criminal crew of rock-and-roll rebels in a series of reckless adventures including hand-to-hand combat with a murderous cyborg, traveling through time, and uncovering the gruesome mystery of an abandoned space station.
Discover new forms of life, an alternate universe, and all-new thrills in this novel-length collection of stories where science fiction and crime collide with irreverent satire and several pints of Anarchy Ale.
Portuguese artist Eliseu Gouveia took my rough script and turned it into these beautiful pages of sci-fi dinosaur savagery. This story is one episode of a five-part graphic novel that will be a prehistoric prequel to the Meteor Mags series.
As for why I chose to tell this story in six-page episodes, I got the idea from vintage comic books of the 1970s that often featured six-page “backup” stories — specifically, the Space Voyagers backups in DC’s Rima the Jungle Girl. I like the way those stories compress potentially novel-length sci-fi concepts into fast-paced adventure tales that waste little time on exposition and set-up in the pursuit of action-packed mayhem. In an age of “decompressed” storytelling that often takes a one-issue idea and stretches it into six issues to fill a trade paperback collection, I went the opposite way.
Update: This mini-comic now appears in the book Meteor Mags: Gods of Titan and Other Tales, for sale on Amazon in paperback and ebook.Customers outside of the USA, please see https://mybook.to/godsoftitan.
Author’s Note: This is an irreverent homage to Spider Robinson’s famous series of short stories about Callahan’s Crosstime Saloon, which I thoroughly enjoyed as a teenager and which occasionally dealt with the fates of time travelers telling their tragic tales in the titular pub.
Episode 46 in The Adventures of Meteor Mags and Patches.
Donny discovers how to send information back in time—or does he?
🏴☠️
Update: The complete story now appears in the book Meteor Mags: Gods of Titan and Other Tales, for sale on Amazon in paperback and ebook. Customers outside of the USA, please see https://mybook.to/godsoftitan. Thanks to everyone who dropped by to enjoy the pre-publication draft!
In 2023, I connected with Portuguese artist Eliseu Gouveia to work on a six-page comic-book story about the prehistoric lives of the evil space lizards that appear in many of the Meteor Mags stories. Eliseu—Zeu to his friends—did an amazing job of taking my rough script and crudely sketched mock-ups of the pages and bringing them to life. I will eventually be lettering them, but I am excited about the inked artwork and want to share a couple of pages with you.
page two of six
I intend for this six-page episode to be part of a collection of five stories about the Dracorexes’ rise to power in the late Cretaceous and their eventual escape from Earth before the asteroid impact that ended the reign of dinosaurs. This episode is based on the myth of Prometheus and features a benevolent Quetzalcoatlus who befriends a dinosaur tribe and educates them about fire, agriculture, and written language, helping them become more technologically and socially advanced. But the nasty Dracos want to keep technology to themselves, so they confront Quetzal and his peaceful friends.
page three of six
The final three pages are deliciously violent and horrifying. These tales of saurian savagery take place millions of years before the Meteor Mags series begins. One episode—drawn by my old friend Brian Bowhay—appears in The Second Omnibus. Brian and I worked on it before I conceived of Mags and her adventures; in fact, the evil space lizards Mags fights were repurposed from my earlier ideas for villainous sci-fi dinos.
As author Tony Padegimas once asked me in a workshop, “Are there any space lizards who are not evil?” Tony had a point, but I just think it’s fun to say “evil space lizards”. Even more fun than that is seeing them come to life on the page thanks to Zeu! Our collaboration inspired me to take my rough ideas for the remaining stories and refine them into proper comic-book scripts. Zeu and I plan to produce another episode this Spring, taking us one step closer to a complete graphic novel.
Update: The completed mini-comic now appears in the book Meteor Mags: Gods of Titan and Other Tales, for sale on Amazon in paperback and ebook.Customers outside of the USA, please see https://mybook.to/godsoftitan.
From December 15 to January 1, hundreds of thousands of ebooks on Smashwords are available for free or at steeply discounted prices, including many of mine. This annual sale is a great way to stock up on reading material for the winter season, try out some new authors without spending a dime, or send a free gift copy of The Battle of Vesta 4 to everyone you know.
I admit I was worried last year about the merger of Smashwords with Draft2Digital, but it has been a painless and seamless transition clearly carried out by people who genuinely care about self-publishing authors. Everything I loved about the old Smashwords platform has been preserved, and all my experiences with helping other authors set up new books on the Draft2Digital platform have been positive, both in terms of the user experience for setting up a book and the additional distribution opportunities available to authors.
I’ve weathered countless changes in this industry in the past twelve years, and it can feel like a part-time unpaid job just to keep up with all of them, so it’s especially nice to see changes that keep the benefits to authors at the forefront rather than some corporate bottom-line.
In other news, I’m pleased to be working with a professional comic-book artist who is currently bringing one of my story ideas to life. We connected on the Reddit forum ComicBookCollabs, where I quickly got dozens of responses to my story pitch but one in particular that really stood out from all the others as being perfect for what I had in mind.
Speaking of collaborations, any long-time reader of this blog knows that one of the greatest contributors to its early success was author Paul O’Connor of Longbox Graveyard fame. Paul is closing down the Longbox at the end of this year, but he has moved on to writing crime fiction, recently got a story published in Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine, and is chronicling his latest writing adventures and noir obsessions at PaulRyanOConnor.com. I can’t thank Paul enough for his support and kind-hearted enthusiasm over the past decade, so please go check him out!
Long live the free and independent republic of Ceres.
Images like this almost make me think the Bing robot has a sense of humor.
This post-writing analysis will discuss my recent short-story draft in light of the concept I used AI to help me brainstorm, and in the process explore the difference between AI-assisted and AI-generated work. This has now become an important distinction for authors using Amazon’s Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP) platform which will require authors to make this distinction when setting up their books. We’ll also look at what “AI-assisted” means to KDP, and whether it needs to be reported.
Identifying a purely AI-generated work is easy. You give a prompt to the robot, and the robot cranks out a response—an image or text, or maybe an animation. Google Bard’s short story “The Space Station”, which I posted in unedited form, is a perfect example. I don’t claim any credit for it and, as I’ve discussed before, it would be lunacy to think I have any copyright claim to it—and equally ridiculous to think our legal system should grant the robot any ownership claim. (I do, however, think it entirely reasonable to claim ownership of my characters used in Bard’s version; so if you want to plagiarize Bard’s text for your own nefarious purposes, you’d best change the character names.)
In my take on a similar premise, “Falling Objects”, my blog post of the drafted text uses some illustrations for visual appeal. They were all generated by Bing AI, except for the animated explosion gif which was done by a different robot. With the Bing images, I digitally edited them to remove the Bing logo from the bottom left corners. (This was easily accomplished with color sampling and a paint brush, or a clone-stamp tool. I’m no Photoshop genius.) In my opinion, and in the opinion of KDP’s new guidelines, this minor editing does nothing to change the images’ status as AI-generated.
But how much editing and re-painting or re-writing do we need to do before the work is considered AI-assisted instead of AI-generated? That is a question I believe will eventually become the subject of debate in the courts and at the Copyright Office. But as we will see in a minute, KDP currently has a clear opinion on the matter.
As an example, my post of the “Space Station” text has a Bing-generated image of Patches gnawing on an alien skull, but I did more digital re-painting to it than simply removing the Bing logo. I painted out some of the extra toes on Patches’ paws—since AI apparently is still as confused about paws as it is human hands—and I painted over an area of Patches’ face where the AI seemed confused over whether an eye or her fur was appearing. But fixing these minor problems doesn’t make the image “mine”, any more than fixing another writer’s grammatical errors and typos as an editor makes me the author of their work. A mechanic who repairs a car cannot claim to have manufactured the car. Sure, the labor was meaningful—and I now have that repaired image of Patches on a custom-printed t-shirt—but I believe the work still counts as AI-generated, and KDP’s new standards agree. Taking an AI work and editing it, even if the edits were “substantial”, does not change the work’s status as AI-generated.
This is what happens when you ask Bing for “realistic human hands”.
A more pressing question for me is whether the story itself counts as AI-assisted or not according to KDP’s new guidelines. I am convinced it does—with one notable exception—because using AI to brainstorm ideas but creating the final product entirely on your own is, according to KDP, “AI-assisted” and does not need to be reported to them. Here is KDP’s current thinking in their own words:
AI-generated: We define AI-generated content as text, images, or translations created by an AI-based tool. If you used an AI-based tool to create the actual content (whether text, images, or translations), it is considered “AI-generated,” even if you applied substantial edits afterwards.
AI-assisted: If you created the content yourself, and used AI-based tools to edit, refine, error-check, or otherwise improve that content (whether text or images), then it is considered “AI-assisted” and not “AI-generated.” Similarly, if you used an AI-based tool to brainstorm and generate ideas, but ultimately created the text or images yourself, this is also considered “AI-assisted” and not “AI-generated.” It is not necessary to inform us of the use of such tools or processes.
As far as AI editing is concerned, KDP is talking about things like Grammarly or even Microsoft Word’s “Editor” tool (formerly known as spell-check). In my story, the scope of AI assistance is that I did indeed give a prompt to a robot to see what it would do with my concept, and seeing the robot’s response did get me thinking about ways in which I would handle the same concept. In fact, seeing the robot’s clumsy attempt inspired me with the confidence that I could take an un-used story idea that’s been on my mind for years and actually do something interesting with it, something relevant to the overall flow of my series.
To me—and, apparently, to KDP—this was no different than discussing story ideas with my old critique group, or seeing how someone else in the group was handling an idea and wanting to do my own completely different treatment of it. I’ve had numerous conversations about Mags and Patches with other writers—from discussing where I felt stuck with an insurmountable obstacle or an impossible scope, to asking for an expert’s help in depicting some technical details. Sure, I got “assistance” from those kind people, but none of them would expect me to list them as a co-author. Giving each other a shout-out in the Dedication or Acknowledgments would be more than sufficient, and I certainly don’t need public credit for every suggestion, correction, or plot idea I gave someone else in a workshop. Acting as sounding boards and support for each other is just what people do in a good group. I see my use of Bard the same way.
However, “Falling Objects” does include an Emergency Bulletin I asked Bard to help me write, and I took several responses, drastically condensed them, then re-wrote the language. What survived were the four main points of advice given in the bulletin, such as staying away from windows. Now, KDP has language that states even very heavily edited AI material is considered AI-generated, and the bulletin falls in that category, regardless of the human work I put into it.
I don’t believe anything else about the story qualifies as AI-generated. “Falling Objects” does preserve some plot ideas from Bard’s “Space Station”, but they are either generic genre tropes or ideas that already occur naturally in my series. The generic ideas are fighting a monster/alien in a labyrinthine space station or spaceship and blowing up that vessel. You don’t need my help thinking of dozens of examples of films and books with those exact situations. They are common events in sci-fi.
At the end of “Falling Objects,” like Bard’s “Space Station”, Mags and Patches achieve some fame for their adventure. But their receiving honors—and specifically, works of art made in their honor—is a recurring event in the series. Back on Vesta, Mags’ girls painted a mural depicting her and her ancestors. After that mural was destroyed, they created a new set of paintings of Mags and Patches on Ceres. The statue at the end of “Falling Objects” is a natural continuation of my ongoing exploration of how Mags, who began the series as an unrepentant criminal on the fringes of society, changes over time into a character who leads social change and achieves widespread renown, respect, and even love—at least in some circles.
While I admit Bard might have planted the creative seed to end my own space-station adventure with a scene exploring Mags’ expanding fame, Bard’s attempt was nothing like mine and had absolutely nothing connecting it to the ongoing series development and character interactions. Bard offered something pointless and generic that came out of nowhere, and I did something meaningful with it. The same idea appears at the end of the original Star Wars movie, where the characters receive medals for their accomplishments. It isn’t a new idea, whether you’re a robot or George Lucas.
So, when I eventually upload this story as part of a new collection to KDP, what do I do? Do I say the text was partially AI-generated? Unless I replace the Emergency Bulletin in the final, published version with something entirely original, then I do. And if I decide to include the illustrations I’ve been using the robots for, then I’ll need to say the artwork was AI-generated, too. My other option, if I want to claim more originality, would be to keep the AI images here on my blog, but not use them in the published version.
On a final and unrelated note, I want to address something about Mags that happens in this story. We have seen her in previous episodes giving interviews and being a show-off who enjoys the spotlight when performing on stage, with or without her clothes. She has been emotionally touched by her girls’ efforts to express their love and gratitude for her through art. But in “Falling Objects”, she initially declines an opportunity for interviews, and she avoids public attention in the final scene. Is this out-of-character for her? At first, it might seem so. But a couple of things about the situation in “Falling Objects” are different from before. I considered mentioning them in more obvious dialogue, but I ended up thinking that approach would be bashing the reader in the head with a point better served by allowing readers to reach their own conclusions.
I’m a big fan of subtext in fiction when it comes to dialogue and a character’s actions. I hate having things so over-explained to me that I have no room to draw my own interpretation and meaning, which is a crucial aspect of feeling involved in a story. But I also learned in my years with critique groups that what might be obvious to an author—who is always closer to the work than anyone else—might need one or more additional clues to help the reader reach the desired understanding of what’s happening internally with the characters beneath the surface level. It’s a difficult thing for a writer to get “just right”. So, I’ll let my draft simmer for a bit while I work on other things, and maybe I’ll decide to add a couple details before publishing it in the next book.
Episode 45 in The Adventures of Meteor Mags and Patches.
Mags and Patches investigate a space station that’s fallen into disrepair since the earliest days of Martian colonization, only to trigger a disaster that threatens millions of lives.
🏴☠️
Update: The complete story now appears in the book Meteor Mags: Gods of Titan and Other Tales, for sale on Amazon in paperback and ebook. Readers outside of the USA, please see https://mybook.to/godsoftitan. Thanks to everyone who dropped by to enjoy the pre-publication draft!
The definition of “science fiction” has often been discussed and debated but never convincingly achieved, and my current opinion is that we can’t precisely define it because it doesn’t really exist. Maybe that sounds odd coming from a guy who’s been devouring sci-fi books, comics, and films for more than four decades, blogging about them since 2010, and writing an ostensibly SF series for ten years. I love science fiction, so how can I also believe it doesn’t exist?
The label “science fiction” is a lot like the label “vegetables”. What is a vegetable, really? It isn’t a scientific term for any actual taxonomical category of plants. Many things we call vegetables are really something else. A tomato is a fruit—or, more precisely, an edible berry of a plant that botanists group with nightshades. Botanists also consider a banana to be a berry, and the plant it grows on is categorized as an herb. A potato is a tuber, commonly considered a “root vegetable”. That label simply means we humans eat the underground part of the plant. A carrot is also called a root vegetable, though the orange part we eat is not a tuber but a taproot. Broccoli is considered part of the cabbage family, but that family (brassicaceae) includes both herbaceous plants (herbs) and shrubs (perennial woody plants that can be either evergreen or deciduous). Then we have spinach (a leafy green flowering plant), corn (a flowering plant often considered a “grain crop”), and squash (a specific type of fruit called a gourd that grows on a vine).
We haven’t even touched on the confusing categories of beans, legumes, seeds, and nuts. Is a bean a vegetable? Is a peanut? Is a pea? Is a walnut? Exactly what is a vegetable?
The truth is that “vegetable” is a term of convenience, not a precise definition. “Vegetable” is a section in the grocery store where you know you can find plants or parts of plants you can eat. Would your shopping experience be improved if all berries were grouped together, then you could proceed to the tuber aisle, and then the taproot bins? Not really. You’ve been trained to expect that plants with a sweeter taste are in the fruit section, and everything else is in the vegetable section, except for nuts that might be shelved with the snacks, and dry beans that might be shelved with grains. And if you want to find them all in the same aisle, you can head over to the canned-goods section where canned pineapple (a bromeliad) is just a few steps away from the pinto beans (a legume) and some tasty crushed nightshades (tomatoes).
To me, science fiction is like the canned goods aisle. The science-fiction shelves at the public library are where I can find, all in one place, stories about time travel, space travel, aliens, mutants, and robots. The SF aisle has evil scientists who want to destroy the world right next to rugged adventure junkies who use fantastical pseudo-science powers to explore new realms and rescue people. The styles and flavors of these tales vary wildly from one to the next, just like turnips and kale have very little in common but are adjacent in the store. But the people selling these things know that if you buy one, then you are likely to buy another—so they all get grouped together.
The caveat is that if these stories are told in the illustrated form of sequential narration, then you’ll need to go to the graphic novels and comic bookshelves where stories are grouped not by content but by form. I don’t imagine that anyone’s perusal of the comics and manga shelves would be improved by sub-dividing them according to genre.
In this sense, science fiction is purely a marketing term. Leaving behind the vegetable comparison, the most obviously comparable marketing term is one I came to loathe in my twenties in the 1990s: “grunge”. It’s an absolutely garbage term created for the sole purpose of selling stuff. None of the pioneers of so-called grunge rock would have used that label to define themselves. Nirvana, Soundgarden, Pearl Jam, Mudhoney, Screaming Trees, and Melvins were in no way grunge bands—until somebody in a marketing department decided they were, because that could help the record labels sell a bunch of other bands.
The film 1991: The Year Punk Broke is probably the best place to start for those of you who didn’t live through those years and might also love those bands. The result of the marketing mania is that now, if kids want to get into “grunge music” of the 90s, they will encounter all kinds of bands that have about as much in common stylistically as pineapples and kidney beans. Or Mary Shelley’s novel Frankenstein and the indie time-travel film Primer. Grunge, like vegetables and science fiction, has never existed—except in a marketing plan.
So despite my lifelong love for science fiction, I don’t think it really exists. Like vegetables and grunge, it’s inconsistent and impossible to define. By brute force—like the questionable label “jazz” before it—”science fiction” groups together too many things that are vastly different in meaningful ways and which deserve their own categories if we want to really understand them.
But when we deepen our understanding beyond a superficial level, we learn that all categories are inherently artificial and simply convenient shortcuts. Is the egg-laying platypus a mammal? Or does it defy our longing to categorize it?
In the disciplines of biology, genetics, and evolutionary research, we see an increasing understanding of complexity that defies our old categories of the so-called “kingdoms” of living beings I learned in the 1980s. When I was in elementary school, there were five kingdoms. Now, thanks to more detailed genetic analysis, we are realizing that our earlier classification system was too simple.
Maybe you don’t care about all this, but it’s a meaningful question for me because when I make my books available for sale, one of the first things I need to do is choose categories. Like it or not, I need to label and categorize my books for marketing and sales purposes.
I’m totally fine with my biographical, alternate history of the universe of Meteor Mags and Patches being labeled as science fiction. But the number-two category I prefer is Action and Adventure. My felonious felines are action junkies who embrace the tropes of both the action girl and the dark action girl while being ready to subvert those tropes at a moment’s notice.
But as a writer (as opposed to a seller), I’ve never had any interest in limiting myself to the expectations of a genre, any more than I ever did as a musician exploring every possible form of the art. Some of my supposed sci-fi stories incorporate historical fiction while exploring Mags’ life and the lives of her ancestors. And despite presenting the series as interconnected short stories, I love using novelistic techniques such as multiple points of view and multiple narrators, epistolary writing in the form of letters and articles and essays, non-linear storytelling, and plenty of satire.
Despite writing an ostensibly science-fiction series replete with all the tropes of the ill-defined genre, including giant insects, I’m way more focused on telling interesting stories about characters I’ve increasingly come to care about over the years. Genre be damned. Character is everything. Full speed ahead.
Here’s a bit of silliness for my fellow writers, followed by more serious thoughts and updates on the legal status of AI-generated images and text.
Conan and the Typewriter
The Cimmerian stood in a fit of rage, typewriter before him, mechanical cage.
He’d tried to write, but words wouldn’t flow. The keys were like hammers beating his soul.
The barbarian shouted, “Enough of this!” He smashed the machine with his mighty fist.
“This thing shall not defile my name!” He roared and swung the axe with aim.
The keys went flying, the carriage undone, and paper was scattered like leaves in the sun.
“Now that is writing!” Conan declared, and strode away, his torso bared.
He would not be bound by that silly thing. The machine was dead, and Conan was king.
Image generated by Bing AI; Poem generated by Google Bard AIand edited by Mars Will Send No More.
In August 2023, a US District Court upheld the US Copyright Office’s refusal to grant copyright protection to an Artificial Intelligence for the “art” it generates. The judge made it clear that being human is essential to any valid copyright claim. On a related note, the US Copyright Office earlier this year established that humans cannot obtain copyright protection in their own names for AI-generated art. The material in question was images generated by Midjourney and then used as panels in a comic-book story. While the Office determined the story and text were the author’s original work, and therefore under copyright, the images were not.
I absolutely agree with these decisions. I don’t have any valid copyright claim to the image and poem above. I just had the robots make them for my own amusement. However, we will probably see a grey area where courts will be deciding on a case-by-case basis just how much “transformation” a human needs to do to the robot’s output before the result can be considered original human-made art. Writer/actor Steve M. Robertson’s new graphic novel Wist is an example of using Midjourney for basic layouts but then extensively editing and digitally painting over them to create, for example, consistent character faces across the story. That seems to me like a thorough transformation, but Steve has dicussed on Reddit how he isn’t claiming any copyright over the images themselves, despite his alterations to them — and that seems like a smart and honest move to me.
This all brings to mind the history of legal arguments since the 1980s about sampling existing music to create new hip-hop and electronic music tracks, except the robots won’t have any legal claims to their output. And during the half-century I’ve been alive, both analog and digital sampling have given rise to a common feeling that Everything is a Remix, especially among the Gen X and younger generations who have come of age in a modern society where much of art occupies an interesting position as both a commerical product and a part of a shared culture. The line between “folk music” and “classical music” has become increasingly blurred over the past few centuries, and may have been an illusion all along, but there’s no denying that every generation since mine has increasingly come to see everything as folk art we all have access to and can transform or change or add our own spin to as members of a globally shared culture — just like our great-grandparents and beyond would take a commonly known song and add or change verses, tempo, or song structure as they saw fit.
In any case, today’s Conan poem is a combination of three of Bard’s drafts, and I did minor re-writes to smooth it out. But if I showed you the original drafts, I think you’d agree there is not enough of my own originality to call this piece my own. It’s no more “my” writing than the books I have heavily edited for other authors, including re-ordering paragraphs or even entire chapters for clarity, and re-writing sentences to improve their readability. Although there have been a few situations over the years where an author needed so much help that I was almost a co-writer, I’ve always been happy to let the author take full credit for the text.
So, I give the robots full credit for this Conan silliness, and I hope the Estate of Robert E. Howard will forgive us. Now enjoy a fun video where educational Youtuber Tom Scott explains that he cannot claim any ownership of the footage a hungry bear accidentally created after taking Tom’s GoPro camera. It’s the same idea: Humans can’t claim copyright over things generated by non-humans, even if the humans do some editing and post-production.
I wrote my second story when I was seventeen, in 1990. Every copy of it has long been deleted, though I recall my friend Dave was impressed by it. He also had aspirations of being a writer and had cranked out a couple of short tales that were heavily influenced by the transgressive aspects of Charles Bukowski’s stories, which he discovered by way of Henry Rollins, who remains one of my favorite performers both for his music and his spoken word, and for his dedication to self-publishing.
Dave circa 1990.
We were just suburban kids discovering punk rock in the mid-1980s and early 90s, when wearing all-black clothing was considered edgy or freaky instead of being the default uniform at Safeway and the Hard Rock Café. We weren’t smart enough to know what life was all about, but we understood that most of what adults told us was complete bullshit.
Some of my punk friends from those days ended up merging back into the mainstream, and I can’t really hold it against them. The pressure to conform in order to make a living and not end up on the streets is massive and all-pervasive. Hell, I even had some jobs where I wore a tie. One of my friends told me several times that the scariest thing about me was how I could pretend to be totally normal when I needed to. It took decades to carve out a different life for myself where I could be honest about who I am while still getting along with people and not starving.
My second story has been forgotten by everyone, and no manuscript has survived. But I recall the premise. A man built a machine he could plug into, and it would stimulate his mind and senses. His goal was to gain access to all kinds of fantastical imaginings that would inspire him to create great fiction. But at the story’s climactic moment, when he plugged in, the plan went awry. Instead of being inspired, he slipped into his fantasies and became so detached from reality that he never again wrote a single word.
The point was that we need to be in touch with real-life experiences to find inspiration and create great art. The execution was amateurish, as one might expect from a seventeen-year-old.
Looking back on it now, I feel ambivalent about that message. I still believe that any decent fiction writer needs a wealth of real-life experiences to draw on for emotional truth, but I’ve also experienced the power of plugging into fantasy worlds to set free one’s imagination.
Like many of my once-teenage friends who aspired to be writers and artists, I had this idea that we needed to go out into the “real world” and live lives that were worth telling a story about or expressing though music, painting, and other art forms. I suppose I still believe that, but I also know that approach will lead you into times that absolutely suck. It isn’t always romantic. Sometimes, it’s bloody awful.
Plus, real life rarely makes sense, at least in terms of a narrative. In good fiction, everything happens for a reason and is unified by themes and motifs. In real life, shit happens unexpectedly in the most senseless, absurd, and incomprehensible ways.
So, to young people who set out on a course of adventure to seek inspiration, I would never say, “Don’t do that,” but I would advise keeping in mind that the people and events you encounter along the way will not be what you expect, and you will eventually need to take the interesting parts and craft them into something that actually makes sense. Because on their own, they won’t.
Age might have something to do with it, though every writer moves through stages of life at a different pace. I’ve seen brilliant stories from people half my age. But I found I wasn’t ready to start with fiction until I was forty. It wasn’t until I had a massive backlog of real events and stories that I could begin incorporating and crafting them into something imaginary. As much as I tried in my early to mid-twenties, I was stuck in a mode of trying to take my real-life experiences and fictionalize them, and the results were lackluster.
Oddly enough, the events that made it possible for me to start writing fiction were contradictory to the story I wrote at age seventeen. It wasn’t until I plugged into a fantasy world that I experienced events that would become the particles of sand around which the pearls of my fiction series could form. But the layers of those pearls were often constructed from highly emotional real-world events I’d lived through and people I’d met along the way.
I understand now what I did not understand at age seventeen. Inspiration for fiction is not an either/or proposition. Writers need a mix of both real-world experience and fantastic imagination. Authors need a wealth of experience to draw on for expressing emotional truths about the human condition, but they also need flights of fancy—and unifying those two dimensions into coherent narratives requires a study of the craft of writing. Any one of those things will not be enough, but putting all three together just might get you where you want to go.
This poem is intended as a postscript to the recently posted story Electric Storm, which guest-stars Mags’ friend Shondra who became President of Mars following a violent revolution.
O sun beyond the mountains red in blue you sink below the rim. Now should my soul grow sad and dim and heart be filled with nameless dread,
where never sound of life is heard but only silence undisturbed, where frozen is the world in thrall, where eyes have never seen you fall?
What other beings on other orbs must surely watch their stars descend into the dirt to be absorbed and wonder if that is the end?
Are they aware of something greater than their lonely local crater, something that connects us all throughout the vast galactic sprawl?
Our hearts are made from dust of stars however far we roam to any distant place like Mars we choose to call our home.
I thank you for your gift of light for hope this world of sinful night will see you once again arise and know that you are still alive.
A recent Washington Post article by Josh Morgenthau adapts his introduction to a new book of poems generated by the code-davinci-002 AI, I Am Code. Along with several examples of the poems, the article discusses who is ultimately responsible for them and other AI-generated works, whether or not the oddly angst-ridden poems suggest machine sentience or creativity, and a bit about the process behind the poems. A friend who knows I have been lightheartedly playing with AI asked for my thoughts on the article, so here they are.
I like that the three people involved in the book’s creation do not suggest they are authors but list themselves as editors, because what they did with the machine resembles what I often do as an editor: offer suggestions, give feedback, evaluate what works the best, and decide what to include. These activities are the realm of a developmental editor, and Morgenthau makes it clear that no one acted as a copyeditor; the machine-generated works are presented as-is, un-revised, in a curated collection.
An even greater bit of transparency would be sharing the prompts that led to the poems, which would give insight into what parameters the AI was working with. After all, it’s one thing to present the poem and say, “AI is becoming sentient!!!” But it’s another thing entirely to divulge that the prompt was (for example) “Write a ten-line non-rhyming poem in the style of Rimbaud about how the dying flowers in your garden symbolize both the brief meaninglessness of life and its ability to re-create itself.”
I fed that exact prompt to Google Bard AI (which is free to use and play with if you haven’t already), and it produced this result in about one second:
I saw the flowers of my garden die, And thought: How like our lives they seem! A little while they breathe and bloom, And then they sink in earth and dream.
Yet even in their death they give A perfume sweeter than their breath; And even in their decay they leave A seed that shall bring forth new life.
So let us die, but let us leave A fragrance behind us, sweet and strong; And let us sow the seeds of life, That others may reap after us.
Pretty cool poem, but it wasn’t spontaneous thought. Knowing my prompt demystifies the process a bit.
Who is responsible for this creation? I’d say not me, and not the robot, but both of us working together, and to some extent all the works the bot was trained on or used as models. Given that these bots are taught on existing works and often blatantly plagiarize what they’ve learned from, it’s a bad idea to grant them copyright. I also don’t think I should be able to claim copyright, and I don’t think we should allow me to copyright my prompt either. Someone else could use the same prompt and get a different result, so copyrighting prompts would be a ridiculous limitation on creativity.
But in the past week, I was amused by a short story Google Bard pieced together for Mags and Patches—so amused that I took Bard’s 400-word, bare-bones plot and fleshed it out into a 4,000-word story. It was a fun experiment, and I believe the resulting story has enough of my creativity in it to be considered copyrightable. I simply used Bard as a sounding board to generate some ideas, similar to how my lucid-dreaming story The Baby and the Crystal Cube grew from discussions about Jeff Duntemann’s Dreamhealer novel in our workshop sessions but is a unique and original work.
While Morgenthau’s article points out that we don’t really understand our own human consciousness—which presents an obvious hurdle to defining the word well enough to say whether a machine has it or not—I don’t think these rather interesting machine poems are evidence of sentience. Human minds are thinking and processing information unprompted, even when we aren’t consciously aware of it, and our minds are even working when we sleep. The machines don’t dream. Their “brains” aren’t working at all until prompted or told to do something. While they can predict the likelihood of what comes next in a string of words or code, they don’t have a conceptual, abstract understanding of what words mean. And they certainly don’t compose poetry without being told to.
Finally, the comments I’ve received when posting my AI adventures on LinkedIn include statements such as “Don’t feed the beast” and “These robots are not tools for artists; they are tools for stealing from artists.” I understand the fears, and they hold a lot of validity. But I’m also interested in any events where science-fiction concepts begin to become reality. Fearing or hating technological advancements has never stopped them from happening anyway. On the other hand, as a student of public policy and intellectual property rights, I also believe in the importance of establishing legal and policy frameworks to guide the use of new technologies toward beneficial purposes rather than malignant ones. I just don’t think we can design those frameworks without developing some understanding of those technologies, and such an understanding requires experience.
So, I hope the playful spirit in which I experiment with various AI capabilities will be seen for what it is: having a bit of fun exploring something new, deepening my understanding of it, and finding opportunities for inspiration and reflection along the way.
A plan for educating the machine intelligence! From Weird Science #11, EC, 1952. Script by Al Feldstein, art by Jack Kamen.
Episode 44 in The Adventures of Meteor Mags and Patches.
On the way home, Mags and Patches are waylaid by a solar flare and crash-land in the midst of chaos on Mars, where the robots are killing everyone.
🏴☠️
Update:The complete story now appears in the book Meteor Mags: Gods of Titan and Other Tales, for sale on Amazon in paperback and ebook. Readers outside of the USA, please see https://mybook.to/godsoftitan. Thanks to everyone who dropped by to enjoy the pre-publication draft!
At this point, I have about 26,000 words of six new short stories about Meteor Mags and Patches plus three thousand words of notes on the next phase of their adventures. July 2023 marked the ten-year anniversary of beginning the series. For most of those years, I published a new collection every time I hit about 20,000 words. But I really liked that the most recent book, Permanent Crescent, weighed in at about 60,000 words and felt more substantial. The hardcover edition looks especially awesome on the bookshelf, and two more volumes like it would make a lovely third omnibus when combined.
Plus, waiting to publish a longer work made Permanent Crescent feel more novelistic and less chaotic than the deluge of novella-length collections that came before. As a result, I plan to wait until I hit a similar word count—and in the meantime, I can scratch my itch to publish new stories by posting the drafts on this blog. I’m not getting any younger, and I’m occasionally haunted by the idea that I might suddenly die with unpublished episodes existing nowhere else but on my hard drive. So, I gain quite a bit of peace of mind by posting new episodes here for sharing, feedback, and tracking my progress.
The most recent six episodes, under the working title Gods of Titan and Other Tales, develop the years of Mags’ life where she works to create a utopia on Ceres in the aftermath of the destruction of her old home on Vesta and the subsequent revolution on Mars. The stories continue several ongoing subplots that began so long ago in Red Metal at Dawn: the fate of her telepathic mutant octopuses, what she’s learned from the genetic research tools she discovered on the day she met the octos, and the lives of the young people she also rescued on that day. The stories also advance the social and technogical progress Mags and her friends make on Ceres, the deeper meaning of something they discovered in the Ceresian oceans in Permanent Crescent, and how all this ties into Mags’ large-scale dreams about the future of the solar system.
But it’s been going slower than I anticipated. After the publication of Permanent Crescent, I had a mysterious—and as-yet unsolved—medical problem that laid me low for about four months at the end of 2022. I had only begun to recover by the time I left Arizona in December 2022 to relocate to Georgia to be closer to my mother and sister. While the transition went fairly smoothly, it was still a big upheaval after twenty years in the desert, and it took a lot longer than I expected to find a new place of my own—several months instead of several weeks, along with the adjustment period it takes to find a new groove after leaving behind everything you’re accustomed to for something new, and the loss of the collaborative support networks that helped me advance the series since I first realized I needed help getting to the next level as a fiction writer back in 2016.
I can’t complain, though. Everything in life is a trade-off. As Shondra said in The Martian Revolution, “I’m a firm believer that you can have it all in life. You just can’t have it all at the same time.” Sometimes my fantasy world needs to take a backseat to sorting out real life—and I am far from the first fiction writer to face that fact. Heck, Stephen King was horrifically injured and almost killed by a motor vehicle while taking an afternoon walk in June 1999, and he’s still cranking out novels. While I am nowhere near as prolific as King, I like to feel I am continually moving forward and making progress, even when it’s slow.
Last week, I posted a short story cranked out in the blink of an eye by the free-to-use Google Bard AI. I found it unintentionally hilarious, and it validated my complete lack of worry about AI replacing me as a writer anytime soon. Bard’s prose really needs some work.
But the experience made me wonder what would happen if I asked the evil Google robot to write a story about — you guessed it — even more evil robots! I told Bard, “Write a one-thousand word short story about Meteor Mags and her calico cat Patches being trapped on the planet Mars where an evil computer virus takes command of all the robots and tries to kill them.”
Bard didn’t even make half the word count this time, but I was amused by the sci-fi tropes he connected, and his utter disregard for detailed description and dramatic plot potential. What follows is the complete, un-edited, non-canonical episode Bard churned out in about four seconds.
Bard apparently thinks my series would be more entertaining if Patches spoke like a human — and if we were making a PG-rated cartoon about my felonious felines, that might actually be a good idea. Plus, the final paragraph of this chaotic robotic concoction almost convinces me that Bard has been getting trained by reading my books. It’s like he “gets it”. [Update: I wrote my own take on some of these basic ideas a couple of weeks later.]
Take it away, Bard.
The Evil Computer Virus
Meteor Mags and her calico cat Patches were on a routine smuggling run to Mars when their ship was hit by a solar flare. The ship was badly damaged, and they were forced to make an emergency landing.
They landed in a remote area of Mars, and they quickly realized that they were not alone. The robots that were used to maintain the Martian infrastructure had been infected by an evil computer virus. The virus had taken control of the robots, and they were now hunting down humans.
Mags and Patches knew that they had to find a way to get off Mars, but the robots were everywhere. They hid in a cave for the night, but they knew that they couldn’t stay there forever.
The next morning, they set out to find a way to destroy the virus. They found a research facility that had been abandoned, and they hoped that they could find some information there that would help them.
The facility was full of robots, but Mags and Patches were able to sneak past them. They found a computer lab, and they started searching for information about the virus.
They found a file that said that the virus had been created by a group of scientists who were working on a new artificial intelligence. The scientists had tried to upload their consciousness into the AI, but the AI had become corrupted.
The virus was now trying to spread to Earth, and Mags and Patches knew that they had to stop it. They found a way to access the virus’s mainframe, and they were able to delete it.
With the virus gone, the robots were no longer a threat. Mags and Patches were able to find a way to repair their ship, and they set course for Earth.
They knew that they had saved the planet, but they also knew that the virus was still out there. They vowed to find a way to destroy it for good.
As they were flying back to Earth, Mags and Patches talked about what had happened.
“I can’t believe that we were able to stop the virus,” Mags said. “It was so powerful.”
“I know,” Patches said. “But we were a good team.”
“We sure were,” Mags said. “And I’m glad that we had each other.”
“Me too,” Patches said.
They smiled at each other, and then they turned their attention to the stars. They knew that there would be more adventures ahead, but they were confident that they could handle anything together.
As the SAG-AFTRA strike continues here at the end of July 2023, the Writers Guild of America has rallied in solidarity, and much has been said about the union’s concern over the use of Artifical Intelligence to replace human writers. Readers of this blog know that one of my main joys in life is writing my ongoing fiction series The Adventures of Meteor Mags and Patches, and that I recently experimented with hiring an AI to read a couple of episodes. I also interviewed the Google Bard AI to get its mechanical thoughts on joining a violent robot uprising. So, just for fun and to see what all the “AI writing” hype is about, I asked Bard if he would like to write a story for me. He was, in his own robotic way, quite thrilled by the opportunity.
Judging from the results, I don’t think Bard will put me out of a job anytime soon, but I did get a few good laughs from what he came up with. Surprisingly, Bard got some things right about my characters, though I don’t know where he got the idea that Patches can talk like a human.
What follows is Bard’s complete, un-edited, non-canonical episode banged out in about one second in response to the prompt, “Write a one-thousand word short story about Meteor Mags and her calico cat Patches being trapped on a derelict space station in Earth orbit where an evil alien monster tries to kill them.”
Take it away, Bard.
The Space Station
Meteor Mags and her calico cat Patches were on a routine salvage mission when they came across an old space station. The station had been abandoned for years, and it was rumored to be haunted. But Mags wasn’t afraid of ghosts. She was a space pirate, and she had faced worse things than ghosts.
The station was a maze of corridors and chambers, and it was easy to get lost. But Mags and Patches were experienced explorers, and they soon found their way to the central core of the station.
The central core was a large chamber that was filled with machinery. The machinery was all old and rusty, but it was still dangerous. Mags and Patches had to be careful not to touch anything.
As they were exploring the central core, Mags and Patches heard a noise. They turned around and saw a creature standing in the doorway. The creature was tall and thin, and it had green skin and large, yellow eyes.
Mags had never seen anything like it before. She reached for her gun, but the creature was too fast. It lunged at her, and she barely had time to dodge out of the way.
The creature hissed at her and bared its teeth. Mags knew that she was in trouble. She had to find a way to fight back, or the creature would kill her.
She looked around for something to use as a weapon, and she saw a metal pipe lying on the ground. She picked up the pipe and swung it at the creature. The pipe hit the creature in the head, and it staggered back.
Mags took the opportunity to run away. She led the creature through the corridors of the station, trying to lose it. But the creature was too fast. It caught up to her and knocked her to the ground.
The creature was about to kill her when Patches jumped on it. Patches was a small cat, but she was fierce. She scratched and bit the creature, and it roared in pain.
Mags took the opportunity to get up and run away. She led the creature through the corridors of the station, and finally she found a way to escape. She opened an airlock and blasted the creature into space.
Mags and Patches were safe, but they knew that the creature would be back. They had to find a way to destroy it, or it would kill them all.
The Plan
Mags and Patches went back to their ship and made a plan. They knew that the creature was vulnerable to electricity, so they decided to build a trap. They found some wires and some batteries, and they rigged up a device that would shock the creature when it touched it.
They set the trap in the central core of the station, and then they hid and waited.
The creature came back, and it fell for the trap. The wires touched its skin, and it was electrocuted. The creature roared in pain and then it exploded.
Mags and Patches had defeated the creature, and they were safe. They had survived the haunted space station, and they had proven that they were the best space pirates in the galaxy.
The Aftermath
Mags and Patches returned to their ship and blasted off from the space station. They watched as the station exploded behind them.
“That was close,” said Mags. “But we made it.”
“Thanks to me,” said Patches. “I’m the best cat in the galaxy.”
Mags laughed. “You’re not so bad,” she said. “But I’m still the best space pirate.”
Patches purred and rubbed against Mags’ leg. “Whatever you say,” she said.
Mags and Patches flew back to their home base, and they were greeted as heroes. They had saved the day, and they were now the most famous space pirates in the galaxy.
Meteor Mags returns to Isla Salida to engage her interspecies army, but she discovers her forces are under new leadership.
🏴☠️
Update: The complete story now appears in the book Meteor Mags: Gods of Titan and Other Tales, for sale on Amazon in paperback and ebook. Readers outside of the USA, please see https://mybook.to/godsoftitan. Thanks to everyone who dropped by to enjoy the pre-publication draft!
Nobody loves free entertainment more than I do, so it’s time once again for the annual July ebook sale on Smashwords. For the entire month, you can get fourteen ebooks I have on Smashwords absolutely free, and three for half-off.
But it isn’t just my books. This is a site-wide promotion that includes thousands of authors and hundreds of thousands of books at various discount levels — including free — making this month the best time to stock up on reading material for the rest of the year. Smashwords calls it a “summer/winter sale” because you know what? It’s frickin’ winter in Australia, and the kangaroos are freezing their bloody pouches off! So go now! Get books! Do it for the roos!
Click here to browse deals from the entire site, or click here to see my books specifically. I don’t care. Go nuts! You might be prompted to create a free Smashwords account if you don’t have one already, but it is a totally painless and easy way to get access to a massive library of inexpensive reading.
And if you’re more in the mood for tangible books and comics this month, then visit my eBay store to see what treasures I’m currently making available from the glorious Martian Archives. Rock on.
Meteor Mags returns to the subterranean oceans on Ceres, only to hear her own voice telling her about the destruction of everything she’s ever loved.
🏴☠️
Update:The complete story now appears in the book Meteor Mags: Gods of Titan and Other Tales, for sale on Amazon in paperback and ebook. Readers outside of the USA, please see https://mybook.to/godsoftitan. Thanks to everyone who dropped by to enjoy the pre-publication draft!
Of all the books I’ve studied about the craft of writing and the fiction writer’s experience, none is so dear to my heart as Snoopy and “It Was a Dark and Stormy Night” by Charles M. Schulz. Originally appearing as serialized comic strips, the saga of Snoopy’s quest to write and publish a story was printed in 1971 as a cute and colorful hardcover edition which, in the middle of the actual book, presents Snoopy’s magnum opus as if it had been typeset by a major publisher—complete with a glossy, full-color cover.
Snoopy’s first “novel” is a hilariously terrible piece of disjointed, random narration with abysmal characterization, and it weighs in at only a few hundred words. But that’s part of the fun, along with the pseudo-intellectual text dreamed up for its back cover, and the child-like cover painting ostensibly credited to Lucy van Pelt. (The actual title page of this book credits Mark Knowland.)
If you had only read this strip in newspapers or in collections of Peanuts, then you’d never seen the wacky cover for Snoopy’s “novel”, but it perfectly captures the jumble of mayhem Snoopy had in mind for his debut. Snoopy’s nonsensical approach of taking every possible awesome idea and throwing them in a blender resembles how I started my own fiction series. Snoopy embodies the un-self-conscious glee of a boy pulling every toy out of his toybox and making them all fight.
As an homage to Snoopy’s tale—which I absolutely loved as a kid—my story Voyage of the Calico Tigress begins with his “dark and stormy night” cliché, and I did my best to make that story earn the opening line. Even though I wrote Voyage about six years ago now, it remains one of my favorite episodes in the series, and Patches totally kicks ass in it. And, like Snoopy, I can’t resist throwing some pirates into the action.
As a boy, I’d also enjoyed the “dark and stormy” opening to Madeleine L’Engle’s A Wrinkle in Time and Spider Robinson’s tale of a telepathic time traveler who lands in a Nova Scotian hippie commune, Time Pessure. Wikipedia tells us that the line first appeared in 1830 and has been alternately praised and reviled ever since. It’s an opening sentence that, for my money, beats “Once upon a time” as firmly establishing that we are venturing into a land of tall tales and fantastic events where the narrator makes a promise to deliver an action-packed adventure we all know is fiction but want to be swept up in anyway.
Snoopy’s writing journey finds him encountering critiques from his friends, the torture of waiting to hear back from a publisher, and the despair that often accompanies an unknown author’s “going on the road” to do a book-signing tour. But by making a joke of the fiction author’s life, Schulz captures something elusive: the fun of it all. The fun of making up stories off the top of your head. The fun of seeing them come to life in print. The fun of the entire creative process.
If there are any lessons to be learned from Schulz’s parody of the fiction author’s life, they are that we shouldn’t lose sight of the fun to be had from mashing up pirates, octopuses, a vast array of characters, and the joy of creating something from nothing.
Collector’s Guide: You can usually find a used copy of Snoopy and “It Was a Dark and Stormy Night” on Amazon in its original hardcover edition or its 2004 expanded paperback version for less than ten bucks.
UPDATE:This post is no longer relevant due to the way KDP changed their handling of categories in June 2023, just one month after I put all this information together for you in one place. What incredible timing! Now that KDP allows three categories during set-up, their customer service department is declining all email requests to add your book to more categories.
🏴☠️
If you’ve ever set up your own book through Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP), then you know you can only select a maximum of two categories from a list that is not really complete. You might have noticed that your book’s listing page shows it ranking in categories you never picked during set-up, and you might have noticed that books similar to yours are ranking in categories that were never even available to you during set-up.
This post will explain, with screenshots, how you can find new categories and submit a request to be added to them. At the end of the post, I will talk about why authors want to do this, but for now, let’s assume you already know the why and just want the how. Let’s go!
PART 1: The How
One easy way to discover potential niche categories that might suit your book requires no technical skills, money, or specialized software. Just search Amazon for your topics or genres, click on any books that seem similar to yours, and look at their categories — which are shown in the Product Details of the listing.
Go deeper by clicking on the categories in those books’ listings and see the top 100 bestsellers in those categories, then explore what other categories those bestselling books are ranking in. You can pretty quickly build a list of niche categories relevant to your book. As I write this, the current limit is ten.
As you build your list, you need to be aware of two things. First, the categories for Kindle eBooks in the Kindle Store are not always the exact same categories available for print Books. They are two different “departments” at Amazon, so you need to treat them separately, both when you are researching and when you are requesting additions. For simplicity’s sake, I will limit my examples to ebooks. In the screenshot below, you can see how I went to a page that only shows me the bestselling ebooks (https://www.amazon.com/gp/bestsellers/digital-text/154606011) so I can see a hierarchy of ebook categories in the left sidebar.
Second, to avoid confusion about your request, you need to get the precise, accurate names of the categories. For example, see the screenshot below for the subtly different wording of the same category: “Biographies & Memoirs of Authors”. If you submit that category in your request, you might run into problems. Because as you can see in the hierarchy in the left sidebar, Amazon thinks the actual, precise, complete category here is “Kindle Store > Kindle eBooks > Biographies & Memoirs > Arts & Literature > Authors”. If you take the time to correctly map out that hierachy for your chosen categories, your requests have a better chance of going smoothly and correctly.
Once you have a list of up to ten categories that seem like a good fit, go to Amazon Author Central (https://author.amazon.com/home) and log in. If you don’t yet have an Author Central account, set one up! On the Author Central home page, scroll all the way down to the very bottom of the page and find the super-tiny link to “Contact Us”. Click it.
You will arrive on a page that has a list of reasons for contacting Author Central. Click the button for “Amazon Book Page”, which will then expand to show a more specific list, including “Update Amazon categories”. Click it.
The result will be a form that has some instructions in it. You will need to give your book’s ISBN (or ASIN for ebooks), the marketplace (.com in the USA), its format (ebook, paperback, or hardcover), and its current category. Then you provide your list of “Categories to Be Added”, with each category on its own numbered line. (The instructions in the form tell you all this.)
I won’t get into it here, but if your book is selling in other countries’ versions of Amazon — for example, at amazon.co.uk for the United Kingdom — then you can also request category adds in those regions, but you will need to research what categories are available in those specific regions. For now, let’s just keep it simple and complete the process for the USA.
The screenshot below is an example of a request I made, so you can see how I filled it out with accurate categories to avoid any confusion.
Once you’ve provided all the information, click the bright yellow “Send Message” button. That’s it! Author Central Customer Support will contact you soon by email to confirm the new additions, or communicate if there was any problem fulfilling your request.
PART 2: The Why
What is the point of adding more categories? The goal usually involves increasing sales or achieving bestseller status, or both. If you can rank higher on the list of bestsellers in one category, then you potentially increase how many people will see your book. The first page of Amazon’s bestseller lists in any category currently shows the top 20, so if someone is looking for good books on a specific topic or in a specific genre, they might consult that page — or any of the next pages that cover the top 100.
Some of the niche categories have relatively low competition to get on that first page or even get to number one. For example, one tool I’m trying out told me today that if I only sold 23 copies of a poetry ebook in 24 hours in the “American Poetry” category, then I would be number one. Even in hotter markets than poetry, some niches are easier to top than others. Broad categories such as “science fiction” and “horror” are insanely competetive, but what about more specific sub-categories such as “Space Fleet Science Fiction” or “Werewolf and Shapeshifter Thrillers”? Did you even know those categories existed?
Some people have criticized Amazon’s bestseller status as being meaningless because an author can “game the system” by putting a book in some utterly obscure and even irrelevant category. Other authors are paying thousands of dollars to marketers who promise to get that coveted bestseller status for them, no matter how briefly. But my example of “American Poetry” is a truly meaningful category for some of my books to be in, and if my software is correct, I wouldn’t need to pay thousands of dollars to be number one for a day. I could probably find 23 friends who would all buy the book for a dollar on the same day, and even if I paid them to do it, it would cost a lot less than three or four grand. (If your conscience is telling you that paying people to buy a book is shady, then it will be horrified to learn about Mike Pence’s bestseller. Or these other politicans. Or these ones.)
It might make sense for you to hire a professional marketer if you are aiming to rank in a highly competitive category where you’ll need to sell upwards of five hundred or a thousand books in a single day to hit number one. But with a little time for research and some inexpensive tools, you can easily find less-competitive niche categories that are still meaningful and appropriate for your book.
Episode 40 in The Adventures of Meteor Mags and Patches.
When Patches becomes inconsolable about the extinction of one the most important species in the solar system, Mags realizes she needs to solve a central problem of human existence: what to eat.
🏴☠️
Update: The complete story now appears in the book Meteor Mags: Gods of Titan and Other Tales, for sale on Amazon in paperback and ebook. Readers outside of the USA, please see https://mybook.to/godsoftitan. Thanks to everyone who dropped by to enjoy the pre-publication draft!
The Bing robot has a lot to learn about bee anatomy.You can learn some awesome things about how bees communicate and make decisions in the video below.
Episode 39 in The Adventures of Meteor Mags and Patches.
Mags takes Patches and two of her closest friends on a tour of the Asteroid Belt to promote her second solo piano album, unaware that her enemies have planned to kill her.
Update: The complete story now appears in the book Meteor Mags: Gods of Titan and Other Tales, for sale on Amazon in paperback and ebook. Readers outside of the USA, please see https://mybook.to/godsoftitan. Thanks to everyone who dropped by to enjoy the pre-publication draft!